The debate over what constitutes “appropriate” content jeopardizes the open exchange of ideas. A continuation of our special series on the threats facing democracy today.
The Grécourt Gate welcomes your submissions. To discuss a story idea of interest to the Smith community, contact Barbara Solow at 413-585-2171 or send email to email@example.com.
The Smith eDigest is sent to all campus email accounts on Tuesday and Thursday each week during the academic year and on Tuesdays during the summer. Items for eDigest are limited to official Smith business and must be submitted by 5 p.m. on the day prior to the next edition’s distribution.
A Transgender Educator Reflects on Two Decades of Identity and Visibility in the Classroom
A few years later, I got a job teaching high school English in Massachusetts. This time I wore a button-up shirt tucked into khakis, and I had freshly cut short hair. But I was still “Ms. Ambuter” and was still afraid of talking about gender at work.
I don’t know how long it would have taken me to come out as trans on my own if a student hadn’t confided in me about their own trans identity. There was no way I was going to let this 10th grader be the first person in the school to negotiate being out as trans. So, on National Coming Out Day in October 2009, I took a nametag, wrote “trans” on it, and stuck it to my shirt.
Over the next decade, I continued to come out in my classrooms. I changed my first name to Ryan. I began using he/him pronouns. I am a gestational parent, and when I was pregnant I taught right up until my due date. He/him pronouns and a visibly pregnant belly felt like a radical contradiction to embody in the classroom.
Teaching as someone who is visibly different requires constant negotiation and hypervigilance. It is hard to be in a classroom—it is hard to be anywhere—when some part of yourself is silenced. When LGBTQ students and teachers are forbidden from talking about gender and sexuality in the classroom, when engaging in content that is deemed “controversial” or “radical” is literally against the law, it is traumatic. It requires disconnection. It inhibits access. I have witnessed brilliant, empowering teachers pushed out of education because the system does not sustain who they are.
As a white transmasculine educator in western Massachusetts, I know I have privilege. When I’ve spoken up about gender with colleagues and administrators, I have mostly been met with something between tolerance and support. Being white provides safety and access. It has made it easier to be out, to challenge norms, to advocate for myself and my students.
Education should show students what is possible. It should center voices and experiences that are marginalized or missing. Sometimes the future of education seems bleak, but in my almost two decades as a trans educator I have found time and again that how we show up matters. I believe that when any teacher who embodies difference stands in their power in the classroom, the hidden curriculum for students is that they can too.
Ryan Ambuter ’04 has a master of education in social justice education and a doctorate in teacher education and school improvement from the University of Massachusetts Amherst.
This story appears in the Fall 2022 issue of the Smith Alumnae Quarterly.